Rosebud, Dublin, Ireland – Year 7º. Breaking News

The Decline of Lebanese Press? A Story of Politics, Corruption, Nepotism and Sectarianism


Uno stupido che cammina va più lontano di dieci intellettuali seduti.
(Jacques Séguéla)



La “volontà di potenza” renzista più che una degna pulsione infinita verso il rinnovamento, pare una sub-categoria delle filosofie motivazionali new-age in virtù delle quali se “thoughts become things” (i pensieri diventano cose) perché le parole non possono diventare fatti? Detto altrimenti, sembrerebbe che sia perfetta convinzione della corte renzista e di Matteo Renzi in particolare, che basti affermare l’essenza della realtà (pardon, di una data realtà, quella di cui sono convinti e di cui intendono convincere il popolo italiano) per definire quest’ultima. Da qui a venirne fuori con le anelanti e usate dichiarazioni che hanno costellato questi ultimi 30 mesi di laissez-faire politico, economico, amministrativo, il passo è breve: “Il Jobs Act è stato un successo”, “L’Expo è stato un successo”, “La Riforma costituzionale cambierà l’Italia”, “L’Italia è ripartita”… e in ultimo proprio l’odierno “Abbiamo dimostrato di non essere il problema”.

(Dal “Diario dai giorni del golpe bianco” di Rina Brundu, prossimamente).

Elie Chalala

typewriter-407695_960_720For quite some time, the Lebanese journalistic community has engaged in an ongoing debate concerning the future of their print media. This occurs at a time already impacted by previous closings of many literary supplements as well as political and cultural magazines, a time when many of the surviving newspapers must lay off journalists, severely reduce their daily pages, or finally close their doors, as in the case of the recent shuttering of a 43-year old daily. To a large extent, most of the Lebanese print media problems remain global, but nevertheless, indigenous or “homegrown” issues do exist.

While experts widely recognize that the introduction of new technologies and social media have impacted conventional media worldwide, Lebanon’s print media, and even its broadcast media, also face severe non-technological challenges, some rooted in the diminishment of the Arab funding resources which used to sustain so many of them.

A confessional state since its inception, Lebanon’s sectarian politics have intensified sharply, bringing an end to a period of some civility where the pages of print media acted as battlefields between ideas. As semi-secular political parties and unions disappear along with many cultural magazines and newspapers, the increasingly acrimonious sectarian divisions have eliminated any need for real discourse on controversial debate issues in favor of diatribe, replacing nuance with simplistic black and white explanations.

The external politics which have bankrolled Lebanon’s publishing industry for decades now represent the most important factors in the decline of the Lebanese press. Despite the downward spiral of their plummeting economies, which has caused the Gulf States to sever their subsidies to the Lebanese Press, those states have still developed a recognizable worldwide media of their own. This has left Lebanese journalism to gradually devolve, losing its aura of professionalism, appeal, and stature, making it less competitive, more parochial, and increasingly irrelevant beyond Lebanon’s borders.

Currently, the decline of the Lebanese press has had little impact upon its political role in Lebanese and Arab politics. Instead, it has inflicted great economic hardship and suffering upon a relatively small but significant sector of the population, the journalists and their families. Here, the journalistic community bears some responsibility because of its weak unionization, due to close ties to publishers, made possible by nepotism and sectarianism. Lack of viable unions has prevented journalists from asserting their independence from management, resulting in an inability to force owners to honor their commitments such as redressing crippling pay cuts, refraining from demanding early retirements, complying with legally required severance payments, and paying all legally due and unpaid salaries for some employees.

Meanwhile, the dependency of Lebanese print media on foreign Arab money has had devastating consequences, leaving it unable to meet challenges independently, and causing its failure to implement sensible solutions for its technological and economic difficulties. Newspapers which started publishing or expanding their businesses by using sizable foreign capital rather than responding to indigenous market needs would rather fold their publications than fall back on their own wealth, as many recent media reports indicate.

Elie Chalala

A longer version of this essay is scheduled to appear in Al Jadid, Vol. 21, no. 72 (2017)

Copyright (c) 2017 by Al Jadid


1 Comment on The Decline of Lebanese Press? A Story of Politics, Corruption, Nepotism and Sectarianism

Leave a Reply.... Lascia un commento...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: